Self-Development Without Narcissism

by Evan on 2014/11/14

 

 

One of the sins that self-development is accused of is narcissism. I don’t go along with this entirely, I do go along with it partly.  In this post I want to explain my approach to narcissism and our thriving.

 

Narcissism and How it Comes About
When a need of yours is not met it doesn’t go away. The need will structure your experience – perhaps including developing insensitivity to longing.

Children need attention (so do adults). When it isn’t provided the longing for it structures their experience. I’m saying that the origin of narcissism is not too much attention but not enough.

[Students who are only praised and not given intelligent and supportive guidance on how to succeed may end up producing bad results, and not be able to tell the good from the bad; but this is not narcissism.]

 

Health is a Kind of Self-Forgetfulness
Health is being engaged with something – we are healthy when we are relating (to someone or something) well.

  • This medium when making art.
  • This person I am present with
  • This topic I am investigating

and so on.

To be constantly monitoring yourself would interfere with this process. There is a rhythm between engaging with the matter at hand and then reflecting; working and resting. There is a flow between paying attention to the matter at hand and yourself. Paying attention to only one part of this process leads to problems. Paying attention to yourself and not the matter (narcissism) leads to problems.
Narcissists usually aren’t terribly good at things.
And those who are good at things have a self-forgetfulness in what they are doing (in that particular thing).

I have had the privilege of knowing quite a few people who perform at a high level in different areas of endeavour. They are all quite free of ego when engaged in that activity (away from the activity, in other areas of their life, can be a quite different story); in doing what they do well they are not narcissists and are quite grounded and matter of fact.

And I have found that those who perform at the really high levels to be quite generous with advice and support. If they don’t know they say they don’t know, if they have advice it is quite specific (e.g. “At the moment you need to work on this” or “OK, the next step for you is . . .”).

There is unhealthy self-forgetfulness too. One type is narcissism – caring only about yourself; the other being only caring about the subject of interest e.g. Artists with disastrous personal lives or relationships; business people with no life outside their work.

 

Self-Development

Self-Development is healthy when it is about engaging well with a medium or situation based on your interest or desire.

It is unhealthy when concerned only with the external (success as the measure of a person) or the internal (happiness or equanimity or joy or whatever).

Healthy self-development means a grounded flexibility, adapting and innovating, flowing from your inner to outer world and back again.

 

What Could This Mean For You Now?

1. If you have spent time majoring on one of your worlds and you still feel stuck it may be time to look at your other world.
If you can’t find contentment perhaps your environment doesn’t suit you. You may want others to treat you differently, have a different timetable, change employment if possible.

If you are still frustrated and all the changes you have made haven’t helped it may be time to examine your thoughts and beliefs about your situation, or your criterion of judgement. If it is something that you feel has always been part of you it is likely that you are running off childhood programming that needs to be updated.

2. If you crave attention, consider if you give yourself attention.
If you were judged as a child for wanting attention it may be that you don’t pay attention to yourself. And you will perhaps not take in compliments from others either. Which keeps you craving attention.

3. Thank others and give credit to yourself.
Think of those who you have learned from in the past. Imagine or feel them with you and thank them for the value they have added to your life.

Think of the challenges you have overcome and the difficulties you have dealt with. Acknowledge you intelligence, persistence and courage for dealing with these things. Feel free to give yourself as much credit as you would give to others for having dealt with similar situations.

4. Take note of the times when you are self-forgetful, when you are just absorbed by what you are doing.
These times give you information about what is healthy for you.

Gradually, with a healthy approach to self-development, we develop our own particular way of thriving.

Any and all responses most welcome in the comments.

 

 

 

Coming Up
In February next year I will be starting a major course about how you can thrive. You can find details here. Get in touch if you are interested.

{ 0 comments }

Living With Phonieness and Fakery

November 7, 2014

  In reply to the question, “What is your greatest difficulty with living an authentic life?” I got this response: being around those who don’t. I guess this was a light-hearted response, at least partly. So here is a response to the part that may not be light-hearted.   It Is OK To Look After […]

Read the full article →

Energy, Motivation and Interest

November 3, 2014

This post is in response to this comment I got in the “What is your greatest difficulty living an authentic life?” box in the sidebar.   This is the comment: Finding something to do in a world where little interests me – so end up doing nothing and not moving on from circumstances I should […]

Read the full article →

Shall Respond Soon

November 1, 2014

I just got this comment in the “What is your greatest difficulty in living an authentic life?” box in the sidebar:   Finding something to do in a world where little interests me – so end up doing nothing and not moving on from circumstances I should leave behind (and want to)!   I shall […]

Read the full article →

How A Label Made Me Happy

October 31, 2014

  Labels Save Us Time and Effort For instance: In conversation I can refer to my friend “Christine” rather than; that person of a particular height, with a certain hair colour and style of dress. I can talk about a political philosophy (say “Anarchism”) without listing its features and distinguishing it from other political philosophies. […]

Read the full article →

A Challenge: Tell Your Story of How You Have Been Shaped by Others

October 15, 2014

This post is stimulated by a post that a friend on Facebook alerted me to: about the West not needing more of the Hero(ine)’s Story.   Which I think is true.   I do think that the adaptability and creativity of individuals is vital and important.  The problem is ignoring our social context.  We Western […]

Read the full article →

Being Hurt and Isolating Ourselves

October 5, 2014

So much for my optimistic idea about being able to respond to this comment in 24 hours. I hope it has been worth the wait.   I received this comment in the ‘What is your greatest difficulty in living an authentic life?” box – to the right of this post.  If you have a difficulty […]

Read the full article →

Shall Respond Soon

October 3, 2014

I got a comment in the ‘What is your greatest problem with living an authentic life?’ box.  It was lengthy and I’m thinking over how to respond. Shall respond soon – probably in the next 24hrs.  Evan

Read the full article →

Thriving #4 what to do in new or complicated situations

September 26, 2014

  The last post was about learning to get better at something: movine from not knowing to the business of being aware of what to do, to getting better at doing it, to being able to do it routinely. This is very useful in well defined areas – sports, the fine arts, business and so […]

Read the full article →

Thriving #3 from unconscious to conscious and back to unconscious

September 12, 2014

  Thriving means learning and getting better at things. Moving from being clueless and/or confused to having a sense of what’s going on and a good chance of getting what you want. A simple and popular description of this process has four phases unconscious incompetence conscious incompetence conscious competence unconscious competence Thriving in an important […]

Read the full article →

Thriving #2 – your habits can help you thrive

September 5, 2014

  Let’s State Upfront That Habits Can Keep You Stuck You can develop habits without realising it. And so you can end up with habits that mean you do the opposite of what you intend to. You mean to get fit but your evening routine means you don’t go for a walk You mean to […]

Read the full article →